Who Was the Real Mad Hatter
It is often claimed that Theophilus Carter is Lewis Carroll’s inspiration for the character of the Mad Hatter, due to his habit of standing in the door of his shop in Oxford wearing a top hat on the back of his head.
In 1935 H. W. Greene wrote a letter to The Times asserting that Carroll had Tenniel model his drawing of the Mad Hatter on Carter. According to Greene, Carter “was the doubtless unconscious model for the Mad Hatter in ‘Through the Looking-Glass’ as depicted by Tenniel, who was brought down to Oxford by the author, as I have heard, on purpose to see him. The likeness was unmistakable.” A few days later, the Reverend W. Gordon Baillie disputed the notion that Carter did not know he had been the model for the Mad Hatter:
“Your correspondent, Mr. H.W. Greene, thinks that Theophilus Carter was unaware that he figured in “Through the Looking Glass”. But all Oxford called him “The Mad Hatter,” and surely his friends, or enemies, must have chaffed him about it. He would stand at the door of his furniture shop in the High, sometimes in an apron, always with a top-hat at the back of his head, which, with a well-developed nose and a somewhat receding chin, made him an easy target for the caricaturist. The story went that Mr. Dodgson (“Lewis Carroll”), thinking T. C. had imposed upon him, took this revenge. In justice to the man’s memory, I may say that I possess a carved oak armchair which I bought from him, second-hand, 50 years ago. It is as good as ever, and the price was very moderate.”
Further to this correspondence, W. J. Ryland, who had originally mentioned Carter in connection with the clockwork bed, testified that he had not known “that Carter was the original of the ‘Mad Hatter,’ but on looking again at the Tenniel drawing I see it is he to the life. To me,” he went on, “he was the living image of the late W. E. Gladstone, and, being well aware of the fact, was always careful to wear the high collar and black stock so often depicted in Punch in cartoons of the ‘Grand Old Man.”
All three witnesses agreed that Carter looked like Tenniel’s Mad Hatter, and according to Baillie the resemblance was widely noticed, but the explanation of this resemblance is clearly based on hearsay. Over the years the Carter legend has often been retold, but no evidence has come to light, either in Carroll’s diaries, letters, or elsewhere, that Carroll ever brought Tenniel to Oxford for any purpose.
According to Dodgson’s nephew, Stuart Dodgson Collingwood, who wrote a biography of his uncle in 1898, during Carroll’s undergraduate days at Christ Church he had a place at a dining table along with an unidentified person who was the model for the Mad Hatter. The author Derek Hudson, in his biography of Carroll, believed that Collingwood’s reference to a model for the Mad Hatter must be referring to Carter. In the first edition of his biography of Carroll he claimed that Carter was “once of Christ Church” and “later a furniture dealer in the High.”
Roger Lancelyn Green failed to find Carter listed in Alumni Oxonienses and concluded that he “may simply have waited” on Carroll’s table, and identified Carter as “at one time a servitor at Christ Church and later a furniture dealer with a shop in the High at Oxford.” For the second edition of his biography, Hudson revised his description to come into line with Green’s, now stating that Carter was “once a servitor of Christ Church” before he became a furniture dealer. However, there is no evidence that either Collingwood or Greene was right about the Mad Hatter, let alone that they both were.
In his reference Collingwood seems to be claiming that the model for the Mad Hatter was an undergraduate colleague of Carroll’s, and not a waiter. “In those days,” he wrote, “the undergraduates dining in hall were divided into ‘messes.’ Each mess consisted of about half a dozen men, who had a table to themselves. In Mr. Dodgson’s mess were Philip Pusey [son of Edward Pusey, the theologian], the late Rev. G. C. Woodhouse, and, among others, one who still lives in ‘Alice in Wonderland’ as the ‘Hatter.’ ”
Theophilus Carter died in 1904 and was buried in Oxford’s Holywell Cemetery (Plot G77). He was buried with his grand-daughter, Bertha Mary, aged 1 year (1882-1883).
- Posted in: Alice's Adventures in Wonderland
- Tagged: 100 Classic Challenge, Alarm Clock Bed, alice in wonderland, alice's adventures in wonderland, Book, book club, Book Geek, book love, book lover, books, Christ Church, Collingwood, Grand Old man, H.W. green, H.W. Greene, Lewis Carroll, mad hatter, Oxford, Revernd W. Gordon Baillie, Tenniel, Theophilus Carter, Through the Looking Glass